In the past, many investors were wary of investing in Public Sector Undertaking stocks. The reason is that the government-owned companies were seen as bogged down by bureaucracy, inefficiency, and a lack of the nimbleness seen in the private sector.
However, recent years have brought a shift in this perspective. PSU stocks have become more popular, thanks to the government’s reforms, attractive dividend payments, and efforts to improve operational performance. Another reason for this was the faith that our Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi brought along in the proper functioning of the government.
The BSE PSU index has achieved returns of 234.3% over the last five years and 81.1% in the last year. Despite this upward trend, PSU stocks are now experiencing a dip. Over the past two months, the BSE PSU index has dropped by 1.7%, which is raising questions about what’s driving this pullback.
Let's understand the reasons behind this decline:
High valuations
The decline in PSU stocks can be linked to their already inflated valuations. Sectors like defence, railways, and capital goods have grown positively in recent times. Hence, these high valuations are now triggering price corrections.
Initially, these stocks were considered undervalued, which led to a lot of buying. However, as stock prices rose, they reached levels where they were no longer seen as bargains which discouraged new buyers from entering the market.
The earlier excitement, particularly in the run-up to the general elections, has also faded, and investor focus has shifted post-election.
These sectors are currently priced at high valuations also because of expectations of improved performance. As investors you should be cautious, as failure to meet these expectations can lead to a negative impact on stock valuations.
Profit Booking
Profit booking by investors is another reason for the falling prices. Following a strong rally, many investors decided to lock in profits, which has contributed to the downward pressure on prices.
Earnings Shortfall
Initial optimism pushed PSU stocks to higher levels, but recent earnings reports do not paint the same picture. Investors expected strong financial results, especially from sectors like banking, capital goods, and metals.
This has led to a correction in PSU stocks, as earlier optimism has given way to realistic assessments. Investors are now questioning whether the previous rally was overly enthusiastic, leading to a pullback in stock prices.
Dividend Policies and Capital Allocation Concerns
PSUs have been known for generous dividend payouts. But as investors become more aware, their approach to capital allocation has raised concerns among investors.
The high dividends suggest a lack of focus on reinvesting for future growth. The government pressures PSUs to prioritise dividend payments over capital expenditures, which hinders their long-term development potential.
Open Demat Account and Start Trading!
Legacy Challenges
Another reason behind the fall of PSU stocks is the deep-rooted inefficiencies within these companies. Originally established to promote industrial growth and self-sufficiency post-independence, many PSUs face bureaucratic delays, outdated technologies, and workforce issues.
Limited Autonomy
Government ownership of PSUs has historically served a strategic purpose. However, decisions in PSUs are frequently influenced by political agendas rather than sound economic reasoning.
This limited autonomy hampers PSUs’ ability to make quick decisions and reduces their efficiency. On the other hand, private sector companies are more flexible and adaptable.
Shifts in Investor Focus
PSUs are slow-growing and focused on value rather than agility. They have become less attractive compared to some new age companies.
Investors are gravitating toward fast-growing innovative companies especially in sectors like technology, e-commerce, and fintech.
Final Thoughts
Looking ahead, the future of the PSU sector presents a mixed picture. Certain areas, such as railways and defence offer promising investment opportunities due to strong order books and good earnings potential.
However, the overall PSU market may continue to face challenges, and if the correction continues, short-term gains from PSU stocks are doubtful. Despite these hurdles, the Modi government remains committed to maintaining key policies, and no major shifts are expected due to coalition politics.
The path to privatisation has slowed due to political and election-related factors, progress is still being made, and more state-owned entities could be privatised in the future.
In the long term, most of the PSU stocks are likely to outperform and give a good return. However in the near term, the growth trajectory is subject to the performance of these companies and can see a further dip in the future.
Financial Calculators: SWP Calculator | EMI Calculator | SIP Calculator | Compound Interest Calculator | CAGR Calculator | Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana Calculator | Retirement Calculator | Mutual Fund Returns Calculator | EPF Calculator | Inflation Calculator
Popular Stocks: ICICI Bank Share Price | HDFC Bank Share Price | CDSL Share Price | UPL Share Price | TCS Share Price | BHEL Share Price | Trident Share Price | IRFC Share Price | Adani Power Share Price​​​​​​​