When the tax on equity dividends was first imposed in the Union Budget 2016, it was the first major thrust for buybacks. A company can reward its shareholders in different ways. One of the ways of rewarding shareholders is through declaration of dividends. But now dividends are being taxed at 3 levels. Firstly, dividends are a post-tax appropriation. Secondly, there is dividend distribution tax (DDT) on dividends that is paid by the company declaring the dividends. Lastly, investors earning more than Rs.10 lakhs as dividend per year will also pay an additional tax at 10%. Before getting into buybacks, let us first understand how these factors add up.
How hard is dividend being taxed in India?
ParticularsDividend Distribution TaxTax on Dividends Rs.10 lakhs not usedTax on Dividends Rs.10 lakhs limit used upName of the companyXYZ Ltd.XYZ Ltd.XYZ Ltd.Investor’s shares held in XYZ15000 shares15000 shares15000 sharesDividend Declared by XYZ Ltd.Rs.100 per shareRs.100 per shareRs.100 per shareDividend Taxation15% on Gross Dividends declared10% on dividend above Rs.10 lakhs10% tax on dividendsSurcharge1.8% (12% on DDT rate of 15%)1.2% (12% on the dividend tax)1.2% (12% on the dividend tax)Cess payable0.672% (4% cess)0.448% (4% cess)0.448% (4% cess)Tax payable17.47%11.648%11.648%
In the above table there is the DDT which comes to 17.47% effectively and on top of that there is the 11.648% tax on dividends if they exceed Rs.10 lakhs in a year in the hands of the investor. The effective incidence of tax on dividends is more than 29% in this case and that is not good news for dividends as a form of shareholder reward. Companies increasingly prefer to reward shareholders through buybacks which explains the surge in the number of buybacks in recent months. Take the third scenario above where the Rs.10 lakh limit has already been utilized by the investor. Here first there is the 17.47% DDT on the dividend which reduces the gross dividend of Rs.100 to a net dividend of Rs.82.53.
Since the investor is holding 15,000 shares, he gets a net dividend of Rs.12,37,950/- for the year. In the second case only Rs.2,37,950 will be taxable dividends whereas in the third case the entire dividend of Rs.12,37,950 will be taxable at 11.648%. Therefore, in this case, the net dividend of Rs.82.53 further reduces to Rs.72.92. That is an effective tax deduction of 27.08% from the gross dividends declared. That is why buybacks are back in vogue in a big way!
How are buybacks taxed in India in the hands of the shareholders?
How is the tax on company buyback of shares calculated? To understand the buyback of shares tax implications, we first need to understand the various scenarios and the tax implications under each of them. We also need to understand the tax implication of buyback of shares in case of listed and unlisted companies as well as in the direct buyback mechanism and the stock exchange buyback mechanism.
Assume that you had bought shares of company XYZ at Rs.800. After a period of 6 months you accepted the buyback offer by the company at Rs.1000. The profit of Rs.200 will be treated as short term gains as the shares were held for less than 1 year and taxed at the rate of 15%. That is the simpler part of it. The real complication arises when the buyback results in long term capital gains in the hands of the shareholder (i.e. held for more a period of more than 1 year). Here are 5 things you need to know about taxation of buybacks.
Let us first look at listed companies. One way to do a buyback is to do a buyback directly from the shareholders of the company. In this case, even if the gain is a long-term capital gain, the tax on LTCG will be payable at the lower of the two (20% with indexation or 10% without indexation). That is because when there is a direct buyback from shareholders there is no payment of STT by the shareholders. So LTCG on buyback is taxable!
Alternatively, the company can also affect the buyback of shares through the stock exchange, in which case the STT becomes payable on the transaction. However, since the STT is already paid in this case, the long-term capital gains will be entirely exempt.
In both the cases above, the taxation incidence, if any, is only on the shareholder and not on the company. That changes when we talk about buyback by an unlisted company. In that case, the company in question is also liable to pay tax.
In case of unlisted companies, there is no tax imposed on the person who benefits from the buyback of shares irrespective of whether the gain from the buyback is short term gain or long-term gain.
The entire buyback may have become slightly complicated after the Union Budget 2018 as now capital gains beyond Rs.1 lakh during a fiscal year will be taxed at 10% without the benefits of indexation. This will be applicable from April 1st, 2018 but this is likely to largely take away from the attractiveness of buybacks, especially for promoters with large holdings in companies.
Buybacks had emerged as a smart tool for promoters and large investors to avoid the payment of huge taxes on dividends. However, with the introduction of the tax on LTCG without the benefit of indexation, the advantages of buyback of shares may have largely diminished.
Share your Mobile Number with us and get started