E
CO
S
COPE
The Economy Observer
4 July 2024
Combined fiscal deficit at 8.7% of GDP in FY24
1
Government investments surpass 5% of GDP for the first time ever
Based on the provisional/supplementary data of 20 states , total receipts of all states grew 7.4% YoY in FY24P (the lowest
in three years) compared to 12.4% in FY23 (and much lower than 16.8% as per FY24RE). At the same time, total spending
grew faster, at 9.6% YoY in FY24P vs. 12.7% YoY in FY23 (and 20.3% as per FY24RE). Total receipts, thus, were at a three-
year low of 13.3% of GDP in FY24P vs. 13.5% in FY23, while total spending was unchanged at 16.3% of GDP.
As a result, states’ aggregate fiscal deficit stood at INR9.0t in FY24P compared to INR7.5t in FY23 and INR10.3t in FY24RE.
As a percentage of GDP, it stood at 3.1% in FY24 vs. 2.8%/3.5% in FY23/FY24RE. It implies that states’ fiscal deficit was
95% of BEs (and 88% of REs) in FY24P compared to ~85% in FY23.
An analysis of individual states suggests that the fiscal deficit in FY24P exceeded their revised targets in four states (AP,
HR, PB, and TS), while it was less than 80% of FY24REs in as many as seven states (AS, BH, CT, GJ, JH, MH, and OD). The
remaining nine states posted a deficit equal to 80-100% of their targets. The actual deficit was the highest at 146% of
FY24RE in Telangana (TS), and it was the lowest – at only 47% of the target – in Bihar (BH) last year.
Within states’ total receipts, while own receipts (taxes and non-taxes) have increased 11.5% YoY in FY24P (17.9% in
FY23), the transfer from the Center (devolution + grants) rose just 2.5% YoY (vs. 4.9% in FY23). The latter was due to a
contraction of 21.8% YoY in ‘grants from the Center’ in FY24P. Within total tax receipts, states’ own taxes grew 10.3%
YoY in FY24 (vs. 19.6% YoY in FY23), while states’ share in central taxes (devolution) grew 19.1% in FY24P, much higher
than the growth of 5.6% in FY23. Thus, states’ total tax receipts grew 13.4% in FY24P vs. 14.3% in FY23.
Within states’ spending, the growth in capital spending outpaced revenue spending for the third consecutive year in
FY24. Revenue spending grew 7.3% YoY in FY24P vs. 12% growth last year, while capital spending (including loans &
advances, L&As) jumped 21.9% YoY, following 16.8% growth in FY23. Excluding L&As, the capex (or investments) of all
states grew 27% YoY in FY24P compared to a growth of 12.1% YoY in FY23.
A combined analysis of the central and state governments confirms that while total receipts rose 13.7% YoY in FY24P (vs.
12.4% in FY23), total spending grew slowly by 10.2% (at a four-year low rate) in FY24P (vs. 12.3% in FY23). While revenue
spending grew 7.0% YoY in FY24P (at a two-decade low rate), combined capital spending (with L&As) surged 25.3% YoY in
FY24P. The combined capex (excluding L&As) jumped 26.6% YoY in FY24P, following a 14.6% YoY growth in FY23.
Our calculations suggest that the GG fiscal deficit was 8.7% of GDP in FY24P, the lowest in four years and compared to
9.2% in FY23. While the states’ aggregate fiscal deficit in FY24 widened to 3.0% of GDP (from 2.8% each in the previous
two years), the Center’s deficit narrowed to 5.6% of GDP last year, from 6.4%/6.7% of GDP in FY23/FY22.
Total receipts of all the
states rose 7.4% YoY in
FY24, marking the slowest
growth in three years
States’ fiscal deficit at 3.1% of GDP in FY24P:
Based on the provisional data of 20
states, total receipts of all the states grew 7.4% YoY in FY24, marking the slowest
growth in three years and compared to 12.4% YoY growth in FY23. It implies that
states’ total receipts were 90.1% of BEs last year, the lowest in three years
(Exhibit 1).
At the same time, states’ total spending grew faster at 9.6% YoY in FY24P, compared
to 12.7% YoY in FY23. It implies that states’ total spending was 90.9% of BEs in FY24,
compared to 92.4% in FY23
(Exhibit 2).
Total receipts, thus, were at a three-year low
of 13.3% of GDP in FY24, compared to 13.5% in FY23, while total spending was
unchanged at 16.3% of GDP.
Data for all states is based on 20 major states, for which monthly data up to Mar’24 is available. These states account for 93-94% of all states’ Budget. The states/UT
covered in this report are Andhra Pradesh (AP), Assam (AS), Bihar (BH), Chhattisgarh (CT), Gujarat (GJ), Haryana (HR), Himachal Pradesh (HP), Jharkhand (JH),
Karnataka (KA), Kerala (KL), Madhya Pradesh (MP), Maharashtra (MH), Odisha (OD), Punjab (PB), Rajasthan (RJ), Tamil Nadu (TN), Telangana (TS), Uttarakhand (UK),
Uttar Pradesh (UP), and West Bengal (WB). Supplementary accounts are available for six states (AS, BH, HP, HR, PB, and OD), while provisional data is available for
other states.
1
Nikhil Gupta
– Research analyst
(Nikhil.Gupta@MotilalOswal.com)
Tanisha Ladha
– Research analyst
(Tanisha.Ladha@MotilalOswal.com)
Investors are advised to refer through important disclosures made at the last page of the Research Report.
Motilal Oswal research is available on
www.motilaloswal.com/Institutional-Equities,
Bloomberg, Thomson Reuters, Factset and S&P Capital.