24 November 2011
Update | Sector: Capital Goods
T&D Equipment
Powergrid awards accelerate; likely to meet 11th Plan target of INR550b
Competitive intensity to restrict margins of equipment suppliers; maintain Neutral
Powergrid's YTD FY12 project awards at INR79b, up 41% YoY; expect momentum to continue. 12th Plan
capex target at INR1t+, ~2x the 11th Plan capex.
Competitive intensity remains high. Transformer segment sees worst of it, with prices declining by 35-40%
in past two years.
Ordering to improve in next few quarters, but profitability to remain under pressure. Maintain Neutral on
T&D equipment suppliers.
Powergrid's YTD FY12 project awards at INR79b,
up 41% YoY; expect momentum to continue for the
rest of the year:
Power Grid Corporation of India's
(Powergrid) project awards in YTD FY12 (April - October)
totaled INR79b, up 41% YoY. After a lull in the beginning
of the year, ordering has picked up lately, with orders worth
INR40b placed in October alone. In the last one month,
Powergrid has further approved investments worth INR39b,
which will ensure healthy ordering towards the year-end.
We expect Powergrid to place orders of over INR150b in
FY12, which will result in total awards of ~INR550b during
the 11th Five Year Plan. This represents an impressive
growth of ~3x over the 10th Five Year Plan.
Ambitious targets for 12th Five Year Plan:
Powergrid
plans to install ~65,000 circuit km (ckm) of transmission
lines during the 12th Plan, nearly twice the likely installation
in the 11th Plan (~30,000ckm, target of 37,000ckm) with a
targeted capex INR1t+, ~2x the 11th Plan capex. While
the target appears ambitious, it will be necessary to meet
growing transmission needs in the country, especially after
commissioning of 80-100GW of generation projects under
construction.
Competitive intensity remains high; but unlikely to
deteriorate further
Aggressive bidding by Chinese and Korean players, who
together commanded ~60% of the EHV transformer/
reactor market during FY08-11, beat down prices by
30-40% over the last 2-3 years. Recent trends suggest
that pricing in the segment has bottomed out and should
not deteriorate further because of non-sustainability of
very low prices. Increasing thrust by Powergrid on local
manufacturing and decreasing proportion of mandatory
import content will benefit domestic players.
We expect competitive intensity in the tower segment to
remain high, though smaller players that were aggressive
in FY08-10 appear to be focusing more on execution.
The big-7 players commanded ~70% of the market over
FY08-10, which increased to 96% in YTD FY12.
Powergrid now excludes switchgear from substation
package ordering. We believe this has reduced entry
barriers for non-T&D equipment manufacturing
companies in bidding for substation execution business,
thereby enhancing competitive intensity in a segment
otherwise dominated by MNCs.
Our view:
Competitive intensity in the Indian T&D
equipment sector remains high, which continues to impact
pricing. We believe that low product prices coupled with
rising input costs will keep margins under pressure in the
near term. Stocks of T&D equipment suppliers are trading
at significant discount to their long-term average valuations,
implying significant risk to near-term earnings. We believe
that while ordering will improve in the next few quarters,
profitability will remain under pressure. We remain
Neutral
on the T&D equipment sector, with preference for
Siemens
over
ABB
/
Crompton Greaves.
Quarterly project awards by Powergrid (INR b)
Pow ergrid Quarterly orders (INR b)
Source: Powergrid/MOSL
Dhirendra Tiwari
(Dhirendra.Tiwari@MotilalOswal.com) +91 22 3982 5127
Deepak Narnolia
(Deepak.Narnolia@MotilalOswal.com) +91 22 3982 5126