Introduction

If you are seeking a path to wealth creation, the stock market is an option, and many investors prefer being indexed through index funds or ETFs, tracking large and mid-cap indexes such as the NIFTY 50 and NIFTY 500. The NIFTY 50 and NIFTY 500 indices are managed by NSE Indices Ltd., a subsidiary of the National Stock Exchange (NSE). They are used as representations of the various segments of India as its economy continues to grow. So, which index is right for you? In this article, we will look at the constituents, performance, risks and potential returns of investing in these indexes, and hopefully help our readers decide which is best suited for their financial plan.

The NIFTY 50

NIFTY 50 is widely considered India’s benchmark index, often referenced in media and financial reporting. This group includes large blue chip companies such as Reliance Industries, HDFC Bank, Infosys, Tata Consultancy Services, to name a few, from the banking, IT, consumer and energy industries. While the NIFTY 50 is only comprised of 50 companies, it contains a major portion of the total weight of the NSE, and the NIFTY 50 approximates 60-65% of the total market capitalisation on the NSE, which is important as a representation of the Indian economy.

Open Demat Account and Start Trading!

The NIFTY 50 has relatively lower volatility and more stable returns due to the strong fundamentals of its constituents. Also, it has consistent volatility (standard deviation). These metrics indicate reasonable risk, in line with the fundamentals of the NIFTY 50 constituents: established companies and good companies based on fundamentals. From 2015 to 2025, being a ten-year horizon, the annualised return for the NIFTY 50 was ~ 11-12% with volatility in the ballpark of 15-18%. The concentrated orientation of the Nifty 50 simply means risks. It is more appropriate for conservative investors or investors entering the equity market, possibly for the first time, and seeking to lessen risk.

Exploring the NIFTY 500

In comparison, the NIFTY 500 is a broader index that includes 500 companies across large-cap, mid-cap, and small-cap. It covers about 95-96% of the NSE’s overall market capitalisation and gives a broader sense of India’s equity market. The positive aspect of NIFTY 500's diversity is that it has better potential for future growth, but it carries larger swings. Mid- and small-cap stocks, which comprise much of the index, are more sensitive to market movements. NIFTY 500's historical data has delivered returns of 12-15% annually over the past 10 years with volatility in the 18–22% range, depending on the weight of mid- and small-cap stocks.

Key Differences Between NIFTY 50 and NIFTY 500

Performance Insights

The NIFTY 50 has a better chance of outperforming in a stable or bearish market cycle; it comprises large-cap stocks with less chance of pulling back sharply. For example, during the fundamental COVID-19 market crash in 2020, the NIFTY 50 experienced a quicker bounce back than broader indices. The NIFTY 500, on the other hand, will tend to perform better in a bullish market cycle due to the rallying of mid- and small-cap stocks. In 2021, a post-COVID recovery year, the NIFTY 500 was up by 31%, while the NIFTY 50 was up by 24%.

As of April 2025, both indices have benefited from the healthy growth of India's economy for various reasons, including reforms, a move towards digitalisation and structural spending on infrastructure. There have been flashes of volatility with the mid-cap stocks in the NIFTY 500 due to concerns over global contagion risk, particularly with rate hikes in the US, the Eurozone, and parts of Asia.

Which Index Should You Choose?

Your decision will depend on your risk tolerance, investment time horizon, and financial goals:

Select NIFTY 50 if:

• You would like investments that are more stable and have lower risk.

• You are a novice investor with a short-to-medium-term time horizon (3-7 years).

• You want to gain exposure to India's biggest companies that pay dividends regularly.

• Example: A salaried professional saving for a down payment for a home in 5 years could consider an ETF of NIFTY 50.

Select NIFTY 500 if:

• You are comfortable with a higher level of volatility for greater potential returns.

• You have a long-term time horizon (7+ years) to see market cycles.

• You want broad market exposure, including mid- and small-cap stocks focused on growth.

• Example: A younger investor building a retirement corpus in 15-20 years could use an index fund of NIFTY 500.

Conclusion

In summary, the NIFTY 50 and NIFTY 500 have different investor types in their sight. The NIFTY 50 provides a stable entrance to India's markets with a large-cap, blue-chip first investment. The NIFTY 500, being broader, allows for higher growth for long-term investors. Understanding your risk appetite, objectives, and investment time horizon will help you align your investments to wealth creation within and outside these indices. Always do your research, have realistic expectations, and consult professional advice before you invest.

Related Blogs - Nifty total market index vs Nifty 50: Differences all investors must know | What is Sensex and Nifty? | Understanding India’s key stock market indices