Section 40A(3) & Section 40A(3A) - Disallowance of Expenses

Section 40A(3) and Section 40A(3A) are specific parts of Section 40A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, that govern when a business expense cannot be claimed as a deduction due to how it was paid. These rules were introduced to ensure transparency, curb tax evasion, and encourage traceable, non-cash transactions. If a payment is made in cash above a specified limit to a single person on a single day, the tax department may disallow that expense when computing business profits or professional income. Section 40A(3A) further deals with what happens when amounts previously allowed as deductions are paid later in cash. Both provisions affect taxable income and must be considered carefully when preparing returns and managing expenses.

What Section 40A(3) means

Section 40A(3) states that if a business or professional payment exceeds ₹10,000 in cash to a single person in one day, that expense cannot be deducted while computing taxable income. This rule applies even if the expense would otherwise be allowable under tax law. Payments by account payee cheque, bank draft, electronic modes, or other specified modes are not restricted under this rule.

Key Cash Limit

• Cash payment limit per person per day: ₹10,000.
• Special higher limit for transporters (like goods carriage): up to ₹35,000 in a day for hiring or leasing vehicles.

The provision is intended to discourage large cash transactions and promote traceable electronic or bank payments. If the limit is exceeded in cash for a business payment, the entire expense becomes non-deductible, thereby increasing the taxable income of the business.

Open Demat account -  Begin your investment journey now!

How Section 40A(3) works in practice

If a business pays a supplier, professional, or any individual more than ₹10,000 in cash in one day, that cash expense is added back to its income because the deduction is disallowed. This increases taxable profits. The section applies to most current expenses such as rent, professional fees, repairs, or services unless paid by cheque, bank transfer, or another accepted mode.

Example:
If an advertising agency pays a freelance designer ₹15,000 in cash on the same day, the full ₹15,000 is disallowed as a business expense. However, if this amount were paid via bank transfer, it would be allowed as a deduction.

Exceptions to Section 40A(3)

Not all cash payments above ₹10,000 are disallowed. Certain genuine situations are covered by Rule 6DD of the Income-tax Rules, where the normal cash limits do not apply. These include:

• Payments to Government bodies (like railways, local authorities) in cash.
• Payments in areas where banking facilities are not available or impractical.
• Payments to farmers or producers of agricultural products where electronic modes may not be feasible.
• Payments required by legal or contractual obligations where non-cash modes are unavailable.

Rule 6DD prevents technical disallowances when cash payments are unavoidable for legitimate business needs.

What Section 40A(3A) covers

Section 40A(3A) deals with situations where:

• An expense was allowed as a deduction in a previous year based on a liability being incurred,
• But the actual payment of that expense is made in a later year,
• And that actual payment was made in cash, exceeding ₹10,000 in a day.

If this happens, the payment exceeding the cash limit will be treated as income in the year of payment, not as a deductible expense. In simple terms, Section 40A(3A) reverses an earlier deduction when the payment is eventually made in cash above the allowed limits.

How these sections affect your Tax Return

Impact of Disallowance:
When an expense is disallowed under Section 40A(3), that amount is added back to taxable income. A higher taxable income means a higher tax liability for the business or professional. Section 40A(3A) can increase income in the later year if payment of a past liability is made in excess of cash.

Record Keeping:
Maintaining documentation of payments, mode of payment (cheque, bank transfer), and reasons for cash usage under exceptions can help support compliance if the tax department reviews your tax return.

Practical points to remember

• Always prefer non-cash modes (bank transfers, cheques, electronic clearing) for business payments to ensure they are deductible. • If cash payments are necessary, keep detailed records of why electronic modes were not possible, especially under Rule 6DD exceptions. • Payments to transporters may be made up to ₹35,000 in cash if strictly for goods carriage and without banking alternatives. • Review your accounting for any old liabilities paid in the current year in cash to avoid unexpected additions under Section 40A(3A).

Conclusion

Sections 40A(3) and 40A(3A) of the Income-tax Act are designed to discourage large cash payments and promote transparency and record-keeping in business transactions. Cash payments above the set limit (₹10,000 per person per day) for business expenses are not allowed as deductions and may increase taxable income. If previously allowed expenses are paid later in cash beyond the limit, they are added back as income under Section 40A(3A). Following non-cash payment practices and understanding exceptions helps reduce the risk of disallowances and higher tax liabilities.